Rare Presidential Dollar Coins Worth More Than Face Value
Presidential dollar coins might not always grab attention, but certain rare versions have become quite valuable to collectors. Although they were made for regular use, some coins gained importance due to production mistakes, limited quantities, and special characteristics that made them highly collectible.
Whether you’re new to coin collecting or a seasoned hobbyist, knowing which Presidential dollar coins are most valued can help you discover unexpected treasures. This guide covers the top 10 Presidential dollar coins that stand out for their rarity and high collector prices.
The Most Valuable Presidential Dollar Coins
Can Presidential dollars really be worth more than a dollar? Below, we explore the most in-demand coins in the series and explain what makes each one unique and highly valued.
1. 2007-D George Washington Dollar, First Day of Issue, MS67
Despite being produced in high numbers, some 2007-D George Washington dollars are worth more—especially those marked “First Day of Issue” (FDI). This label is only given when coins are sent to top grading companies like PCGS or NGC on February 15, 2007, the release date.
With more than 163 million struck in Denver and 176 million in Philadelphia, these are common coins. However, just two have a MS67 grade from PCGS. One sold for $228 on eBay in 2012, and PCGS now estimates its value at $475.
2. (2007) George Washington Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS68
In 2007, some Washington dollars were issued without edge inscriptions, missing the mint mark and the phrase “In God We Trust.” This mistake earned them the name “Godless Dollars.” One MS67 example sold for $1,007 in 2010.
As more of these error coins appeared, their value dropped. Today, PCGS places an MS67 at $260. Only three MS68 coins are known, each valued at $4,250.
3. (2007) Thomas Jefferson Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS68
Another edge-lettering error coin from 2007 features Thomas Jefferson. When these coins first emerged, they fetched high prices—one MS66 sold for $1,725 in 2009. Now that over 700 are known in that grade, they go for just over $100.
Only one coin has been graded MS68, the highest ever for this type, and it carries a PCGS value of $6,500.
4. (2007) James Madison Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS67
The 2007 James Madison dollar also had edge-lettering mistakes. Although over 200 million coins were minted, the errors are still fairly uncommon.
One MS66-graded coin sold for $441 in 2013, and PCGS now values it at $600. The finest graded version, an MS67, is estimated to be worth $4,000, though no public sale has occurred.
5. (2008) John Quincy Adams Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS68
Even though collectors had already seen edge-lettering errors, the 2008 John Quincy Adams dollar missing this detail still drew interest. An MS66 coin sold for $1,104 in 2012. PCGS now values this grade at $200.
Seventeen MS68-graded coins are known, and each of them carries a valuation of $425.
6. 2008-D Andrew Jackson Dollar – Position A, MS67
Honoring the seventh president, the 2008 Andrew Jackson dollar came in two edge-lettering types: Position A and Position B. The designation depends on the direction of the lettering.
Coins in Position A with an MS67 grade are the most desired. PCGS has certified only seven of these, and each is valued at $370.
7. (2008) Andrew Jackson Dollar – Satin Finish, Missing Edge Lettering, SP69
Satin finish versions were made for collectors and featured a smoother appearance. A few Andrew Jackson dollars were mistakenly made without edge lettering in this format.
Most are graded SP67, but only two have received the nearly perfect SP69 grade. These rare coins are each estimated at $1,000 by PCGS.
8. 2009-P John Tyler Dollar – Position A, MS68
By 2009, the mintage for Presidential dollars began to decline. Only around 87 million John Tyler dollars were produced. One MS67 Position A coin once brought in $1,150 at auction.
But as more high-quality examples were found, its value dropped to $225. The top MS68 version is now estimated by PCGS to be worth $900.
9. (2009) William Henry Harrison Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS69
This 2009 Harrison dollar includes examples that are missing the edge lettering. Lower-grade errors, like MS63, are worth about $30, while MS67+ coins reach up to $200.
A high-grade MS69 example—the best known—sold for $456 in 2019 and later resold in 2022 for $1,250.
10. (2010) Millard Fillmore Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS69
Released in 2010, the Millard Fillmore dollar had the same edge-lettering error. Coins in MS65 grade are easy to find and valued at about $40, though one did sell at auction for $646.
The single best specimen, graded MS69 and unique, has never been sold publicly but is valued by PCGS at $5,500.
Are Presidential Dollar Coins Valuable?
Usually, Presidential dollars you find in your pocket change are only worth one dollar. But coins in excellent condition—especially those with rare errors or special finishes—can sell for hundreds or even thousands of dollars.
FAQs
Q1: What makes a Presidential dollar coin valuable?
Unusual errors, high condition grades, low production numbers, and labels like “First Day of Issue” often raise a coin’s value.
Q2: Where is the mint mark on a Presidential dollar coin?
The mint mark appears along the edge of the coin and will be either a “P” for Philadelphia or a “D” for Denver.
Q3: Are missing edge lettering Presidential dollars rare?
Yes, they are rare, especially in top condition or when paired with other unusual traits or finishes.
Q4: Can I find valuable Presidential dollar coins in circulation?
It’s not impossible, but it’s rare. Most of the high-value coins are either well-preserved or come from special collector issues.
Susan is a seasoned finance writer with a knack for breaking down complex money topics into clear, actionable advice. With years of experience in personal finance, investing, and market trends, she empowers readers to make smarter financial decisions. Her work has been featured in leading finance blogs and publications, where she combines sharp analysis with relatable storytelling. Whether it’s budgeting, wealth-building, or decoding the latest economic shifts, Susan’s mission is to help people take control of their financial future with confidence.